AND PHARISEES

The Bible is not a book. It is a library with 66 books if you're Protestant, 73 if you're Roman Catholic, 81 if you're Orthodox, and 24 if you're a Jew. Those 24 books (or scrolls) which make up the Hebrew Bible was Jesus's library. Christians have appropriated the Hebrew Bible, turned the 24 books into 39, and call it Old Testament. The New Testament is 27 diverse interpretations of Jesus and what it means to follow him.

Sunday's lection, from Matthew 23. 1-12 with its shorter parallels in Mark and Luke, clearly illustrates this diversity in Scripture. Whose voice are we hearing? The Historical Jesus of the 30's, Mark's Jesus of the 70's, or Matthew's Jesus of the 90's? The synoptics points out the hypocrisy of the teachers of the law or the scribes. Matthew's version adds "and pharisees."

That's how we know that Matthew's extended discourse addresses the growing conflict between the Jews and the Christians in the 90s. After the Roman Jewish War of the early 70s that destroyed the temple in Jerusalem, two Jewish communities began to take different yet parallel paths. One was Rabbinic Judaism, with its synagogues, grounded on the written and oral Torah. The other group was made of Jews who believed that the Messiah has arrived and whose community eventually expanded to include the uncircumcised.

This explains the several "and pharisees" in the passage. In other words, Matthew was saying, if Jesus were here he would be saying all these things against these pharisees.

We do something similar all the time. We try to make Jesus address our contemporary situations. If Jesus were here, what would Jesus do? If Jesus were here, would he support Netanyahu and the IDF? If Jesus were here, would he not be in Gaza among the Palestinians right now? If Jesus were here, would you be on the same side? We have actually pushed this appropriation too far by proclaiming JESUS IS THE ANSWER to every question.

Dear friends, if Jesus were here and he was the answer, he'd probably be executed within a year because he would not be the answer most of us want him to be.

*art, "Christ Teaches Humility" by Robert Scott Lauder (1803-1869), from the vanderbilt divinity library digital archives,