Most of us grew up with this parable. Almost every sermon on Matthew 25:31–46 challenges us to be like the sheep and warns us against becoming goats. If we love God, we must care for the least among our sisters and brothers. If we don't, then perhaps we don't really love God.
Some Christians even read this as a parable about salvation: the sheep are the saved who will inherit heaven; the goats are the unsaved condemned to eternal damnation.
Amy-Jill Levine, one of my two Jewish teachers in graduate school, used to tease us: "If you end up in heaven and there are two lines, take the sheep line."
I call this the "Parable of the Great Surprise" because BOTH groups were surprised! The blessed did not expect their blessing. The condemned did not anticipate their fate.
But here's what we often miss: this parable is not about charity, religious orthodoxy, or even loving God. The sheep did not purposefully feed the hungry, welcome the stranger, or visit the imprisoned to earn God's favor. They did not even know they were serving Christ!
The goats, meanwhile, failed to recognize the humanity of those who needed them. They failed their neighbors.
Read from below--from the location of the hungry, the dispossessed, and the imprisoned--this parable is a radical indictment of a world that teaches us to look away from suffering. It demands more than charity. It demands that we recognize our neighbors as human beings whose lives matter, not as opportunities to earn divine favor.
The blessing is grounded in what we do for people for their own sake, not what we do for people to get something from God.
Surprised?! SURPRISE!
P.S. The State of Israel and the Israeli Occupation Forces have gone beyond the goats' indifference. Under the banner of "self-defense," they have weaponized hunger, dispossessed communities, dehumanized Palestinians, and taken countless lives. This is not merely a failure of neighborly love. It is the violent exercise of imperial power against one's neighbors, against those whose lands they stole. If the goats are condemned for refusing to feed the hungry, what judgment awaits those who deliberately make entire populations starve?
*Art: "Food for the Hungry, Drink for the Thirsty," relief sculpture at the Hospital of the Holy Spirit, Biberach, Germany. Vanderbilt Divinity Library Digital Archives.
#ChooseJustice
#FreePalestine
#JusticeForMyanmar
#LoveGodServePeople
#NoToPaxSilica